Replaces yogurt
Dairy-free yogurt: make soy yogurt at home or pick a good one
Quick answer
- 1 cup yogurt
- 1 cup plain unsweetened plant yogurt, soy or another legume base for the most protein
- Homemade
- 4 cups unsweetened soy milk + 1 heaping tbsp plant yogurt with live cultures
- Incubate
- 110 to 115 °F (43 to 46 °C), 8 to 12 hours
- On the label
- calcium fortified, low in added sugar, live and active cultures
Dairy-free yogurt is plant milk set by the same lactic cultures that make dairy yogurt. Plain soy yogurt replaces dairy yogurt cup for cup, and the cheapest one is the one you make: a carton of soy milk, one spoonful of a yogurt you already have, and a warm night.
Soy first
Soy milk has the most protein of the common plant milks, about 7 to 8 g a cup against 1 to 2 g for almond and oat (see the table on plant milks), and protein is what the cultures’ acid sets into a thick yogurt. That is why the homemade recipes we checked use soy milk, ideally one made only from soybeans and water.
Per 100 g, from USDA data:
| Yogurt, plain | Calories | Protein | Fat | Calcium | Sugars |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Soy (USDA 175227) | 66 | 2.6 g | 1.8 g | 132 mg | 5.3 g |
| Dairy, whole milk (USDA 171284), for comparison | 61 | 3.5 g | 3.3 g | 121 mg | 4.7 g |
Brands differ a lot, so the label of the one you buy is what counts.
What to look for on the label
A 2021 survey of 249 plant yogurts from 34 brands sold in the western United States found big gaps between products:
- Protein: the median was 3 g per serving, but every legume based one (soy, pea, fava) had a median of 6 g.
- Calcium: only 45% were fortified to at least 10% of the daily value.
- Vitamin D and B12: only about one in five had at least 10% of the daily value.
- Sugar: half had high sugar levels; 93% were low in sodium.
So the useful filter is short: plain or unsweetened, a soy or other legume base, calcium on the nutrition panel, and “live and active cultures” if you want to use it as a starter.
Why the name changes
In the US, “yogurt” has a legal definition: a food made by culturing dairy ingredients with Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus and Streptococcus thermophilus. Plant versions fall outside it. FDA’s 2025 draft guidance on plant based alternatives asks that the name say the base, so a soy yogurt and an almond yogurt are told apart.
Cooking with it
Plain soy yogurt works in baking like dairy yogurt: its acid reacts with baking soda to lift cakes, muffins and pancakes, and it keeps the crumb moist. If the recipe uses buttermilk instead, see vegan buttermilk.
In hot food it is less forgiving: boiled, it separates and curdles. Take the pan off the heat and stir it in at the end, or mix a little cornstarch or flour into it first. For a rich sauce that has to simmer, use a heavy cream substitute instead.
For cold dips and dressings it needs nothing: grated cucumber, garlic and lemon make a tzatziki style dip, and a spoonful replaces part of the mayo in a creamy dressing with much less fat.
How to make soy yogurt at home
You need: 4 cups unsweetened soy milk, ideally only soybeans and water, 1 heaping tbsp plain plant yogurt with live active cultures.
- Warm the soy milk gently and let it settle at 110 to 115 °F (43 to 46 °C); never boil it once the starter is in, heat kills the cultures.
- Gently stir in the spoonful of plant yogurt.
- Pour into a clean jar and keep it at 110 to 115 °F (43 to 46 °C): a yogurt maker, or the oven switched off.
- Leave it 8 to 12 hours without stirring; the longer it sits, the thicker and more sour it gets (up to 24 hours for very tart).
- Chill it for a few hours before eating; it firms up in the fridge. Save a heaping spoonful as the starter for the next batch and use it within 10 days.
When it works and when it fails
Works well
- Breakfast bowls with fruit and oats, and smoothies
- Cakes, muffins, pancakes and quick breads, where its acid helps baking soda lift the batter
- Cold sauces and dressings: tzatziki style dips, raita, creamy salad dressings
Fails or disappoints
- Boiling or very hot dishes: it separates and curdles, so stir it in at the end
- Sweetened or vanilla yogurt in savory food
- As a calcium source when the label shows no fortification: many plant yogurts are not fortified
Questions
What is the best dairy-free yogurt?
Plain, unsweetened soy yogurt or another legume base (pea, fava). In a survey of 249 plant yogurts, the legume ones had a median of 6 g protein per serving against 3 g for the whole group. Pick one fortified with calcium.
Can I make dairy-free yogurt at home?
Yes. Stir 1 heaping tablespoon of plant yogurt with live cultures into 4 cups of warm unsweetened soy milk and keep it at 110 to 115 °F (43 to 46 °C) for 8 to 12 hours.
Is dairy-free yogurt as nutritious as dairy yogurt?
Not automatically. Plain soy yogurt can match it on calcium when fortified, but in a 2021 US survey only 45% of plant yogurts had at least 10% of the daily value of calcium, and about one in five had enough vitamin D and B12.
Why is it not called just yogurt in the US?
The US standard of identity defines yogurt as a cultured dairy food. FDA's 2025 draft guidance asks plant based versions to name their base, such as soy or almond.
Can I cook with dairy-free yogurt?
Yes, in baking and cold sauces it works like dairy yogurt. In hot dishes it curdles if boiled: take the pan off the heat and stir it in at the end.
Related swaps
- Replaces milkPlant milksSoy, oat, almond, rice and coconut compared: which to bake with, which for coffee.
- Replaces buttermilkButtermilk1 cup plant milk + 1 tbsp lemon juice or vinegar, 5 to 10 minutes. Soy works best.
- Replaces heavy creamHeavy creamCoconut cream to whip, cashew cream for sauces, soy milk with vegan butter.
- Replaces mayonnaiseVegan mayoAquafaba or soy milk with oil, or an oil free silken tofu version.
Sources
Ratios and temperatures were checked against these pages on 2026-11-04. Where they disagreed, we give the range.
- Craig and Brothers, Nutritional content and health profile of non-dairy plant-based yogurt alternatives, Nutrients 2021
- 21 CFR 131.200, Yogurt (US standard of identity, eCFR)
- FDA draft guidance: Labeling of plant-based alternatives to animal-derived foods (2025)
- USDA FoodData Central 175227, plain soy yogurt
- USDA FoodData Central 171284, plain whole milk yogurt
- Homemade unsweetened soy yogurt (Fat Free Vegan Kitchen)
- How to make soy yogurt (Alphafoodie)
- Can you use soy yogurt in cooking? (Girl and the Kitchen)
Cooking advice, not health advice. Last checked 2026-11-04. How we make this site